He Leadeth Me by Walter J. Ciszek, S.J.

Fr. Ciszek was a Jesuit priest who, in 1928 as a young man, answered Pope Pius XI’s call to train for the “Russian missions.”   Fr. Ciszek was imprisoned in Siberia for twenty-three years and returned to the United States in 1963.  He was an American from Shenandoah, Pennsylvania!  I had labored under the impression that he was Polish by birth, a European long accustomed to totalitarian oppression. 

The book is intense, concentrated, even ponderous at times.  First, there is the matter of just following the sequence of events--where Father Ciszek was and when, why he was imprisoned, solitary confinement, the interrogations, hunger, doubt, his transfer to a slave labor camp, physical suffering, facing and surviving a firing squad, “freedom” in Siberia and then his return to the United States.  Plenty to digest.

Then there is the theological and spiritual side with the lesson that Fr. Ciszek drives home over and over.  I took it to be this:  Thy will, Lord, not mine.  He recounts how he came to understand and accept his imprisonment.  He instructs us to be grateful and stalwart servants of the Lord, able always to bend to God’s will, never presuming we can go it alone.  Life isn’t casual.  People are not random physical bodies created to chase sunshine and  rainbows. Every hair of one’s head is accounted for.   Your life has meaning.   Go about figuring it out.

Joseph Gilmore and William Bradbury

Lord, I would clasp Thy hand in mine,

Nor ever murmur nor repine,

Content, whatever lot I see,

Since ‘tis my God that leadeth me!

 

He leadeth me, He leadeth me,

By His own hand He leadeth me:

His faithful foll’wer I would be,                              For by His hand He leadeth me.

 

Four Books About War: The Red Badge of Courage, A Walk In The Sun, All Quiet on the Western Front and The Bridge Over The River Kwai

There are virtually no women in these books. They are books about men and war. War changes a man’s priorities, his judgment, his morality.  War educes from men an array of manly virtues. Men at war demonstrate bravery, loyalty and heroism. They carry heavy loads and march long distances.   They defend, protect, fight, kill, sacrifice, suffer and, in many cases, die.  

Some men, like Henry Fleming in The Red Badge of Courage ask, Will I be brave enough? Will I be scared? Will I cut and run?  Others like Sergeant Porter, A Walk In The Sun, unquestioningly give their all but crack under pressure.  Still others, like some of Sergeant Porter's soldiers, handle the pressure with a cynical humor and optimism.  They wise-crack, tease and talk about home knowing as they do that their walk in the sun may be their last.

 German soldiers in All Quiet on the Western Front face the chaos head on.  This book, dark and hopeless in contrast to  A Walk In The Sun, is graphic in its depiction of death, mangled bodies, amputations, blood and pain. Paul Baumer, the young soldier protagonist in this tale, does not so much question his courage and manliness as he questions war, its purpose and his reason for being there. 

The most artful story-telling is found in The Bridge Over the River Kwai.  British POWs in WWII are forced to build a bridge as part of the Burma-Siam railway.  It's all for the “great empire,” the enemy. Colonel Nicholson will tolerate nothing short of obedience to the law and strict adherence to a gentleman’s code of honor. Colonel Nicholson never weakens and never gives less than one hundred percent. Neither do Warden, Joyce and Shears in Force 316.  Perversely for all, obedience and honor lead to disaster.  Warden, who took the “only line of conduct possible,” destroys his allies;  Nicholson, who carried out orders, saves the enemy’s bridge.  War stands reality on its head. 

The weakest of these four novels was The Red Badge of Courage which I found to move slowly without much plot.  I was never quite sure what the main character, Henry Fleming, was all about.  The other three novels, not necessarily with much more plot, were more satisfying in their message and drew me into the dilemma and plight of the men.  I have seen none of the movies associated with any of the books and I'm not eager to see any of them because I liked the books.  

Reading History #10 Fait Accompli

The first link below will take you to my most recent video which has been quite a long time in the making.  As you will see, I have finished Will Durant's eleven volume The Story of Civilization (which I variously and erroneously refer to as The History of Civilization)!   

Reading History #10 - YouTube

The next few links are to my most recent book commentaries which have also been a long time in the making.  Alas, I don't think I'll come close to reading 100 books this year, 2023, one of my goals, but I am catching up with a lot of fiction which has been sitting idly on our home library shelves.

Shelf Life: The Next Pope by Edward Pentin (amyshelflife.blogspot.com)

Shelf Life: Anatomy of a Murder by Robert Traver (amyshelflife.blogspot.com)

Shelf Life: Four Books About War: The Red Badge of Courage, A Walk In The Sun, All Quiet on the Western Front and The Bridge Over The River Kwai (amyshelflife.blogspot.com)

The Next Pope by Edward Pentin

 

Nineteen cardinals who might be pope are profiled in this lengthy book which is a thoroughly researched study including copious footnotes and pleasant, full-page color photos of each candidate.  These “leading candidates” as the subtitle refers to them represent four continents. 

There are three from Africa (Cardinals Napier, Sarah and Turkson), two from Asia (Cardinals Ranjith and Tagle), three from North America (Cardinals Burke, O’Malley and Ouellet) and the remaining 11 are from Europe with just over half that representation belonging to the Italians (Cardinals Bagnasco, Parolin, Piacenza, Ravasi, Scola and Zuppi).  The other European countries represented are the Czech Republic (Cardinal Duka), the Netherlands (Cardinal Eijk), Germany(Cardinal Muller), Erdo (Hungary) and Austria (Cardinal Schonbrun). 

This book offers insight into the minds of men who have devoted themselves to the Church and who operate at high levels within an ossified and unwieldy bureaucracy (if that’s not redundant).  They range from noble-born to the son of a communist truck driver.  They might be a scholarly heavyweight or an intellectual lightweight.  They may preside over dancing at the altar or they may express concern over any variation in the liturgy.  They may behave with modest decorum as regards their public position while others clearly enjoy the spotlight.  Some of the few common points among them are age---the youngest is approaching 70 and the oldest is 82--a belief in the real presence and the grave evil of abortion. 

So thoroughly did I become drawn in to the other-worldly world of these cardinals that I was compelled to put other reading aside until I had finished Mr. Pentin’s book.  What I had anticipated would be a dry, encyclopedic kind of coverage was anything but.  Edward Pentin allowed the cardinals to speak for themselves and he arranged the material by topics making it easy to jump in at any point or to easily access information about each cardinal. 

I highly recommend this book.

************************************************

What follows are some of my observations based on mere speculation and first impressions, perhaps frivolous.  I also made my own list of cardinal favorites. 

Cardinal Tagle from the Philippines comes in dead last as a promising future pope. He is dubbed the “Asian Francis” and appears to have not much in his head in the way of brains.  As disastrous as Tagle, would be Ravasi, Zuppi, Schonbrun or Parolin. Ravasi is the cardinal who arranged the Vatican costumes for the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York back in 2018.  Zuppi finds his inspiration in the Sant’Egidio community.  Parolin is the Vatican Secretary of State, politician par excellence, very involved in the current China policy of the Vatican.  Cardinal Schonbrun is some version of a soft, accommodate-the-culture Catholic on most issues.  Cardinals Turkson and Napier were surprisingly undynamic. 

As for our North American cardinals, I fear none are destined for the Chair of Peter simply because they don’t speak enough languages!  Cardinal O’Malley might be described as fluent in Spanish and naturally Cardinal Ouellet would speak French. But none of our three North Americans is mentioned as having Italian among their languages or fluency in anything other than their native tongue.  Meanwhile, their brother cardinals across the pond are described as fluent in anywhere from 5 to 10 languages.  Cardinal Ranjith is said to command English, Hebrew, Sinhalese and everything in between, a total of 11 languages! 

Also, by virtue of our history, our North American cardinals do not deal with the range of problems that the other cardinals face---the legacies of communism and colonialism, proximity of Muslim countries, poverty and health epidemics such as AIDS or malaria, polygamy, the consequences of underdevelopment such as lack of transportation, potable water and so on.   Here in North America, we are confronted with neither the atheism of the Czech Republic nor (sterile, secular Canada and even the USA aside for a moment) the depth of secularism in the Netherlands where less than 5% of self-proclaimed Catholics attend mass. We increasingly feel our religious freedoms threatened, but we are not, as in Sri Lanka, a Catholic minority in a predominantly Buddhist culture. 

Most unusual were the impressions I took away of German Cardinal Muller and the American Cardinal Burke.  Both cardinals, highly moral and exceedingly competent men, are frequently interviewed on EWTN when the more traditional Catholic perspective is wanted.  They sound forth eloquently on many issues about which it’s obvious that they’ve thought deeply.  When Cardinal Burke speaks one can almost feel the intellect and faith at work. Yet, given the international character of the papacy, Cardinal Burke seems so solidly American and Midwestern that he is more logically suited to remaining on our national stage. 

Cardinal Muller is a man who appears to exist almost in the ether. His reasoned thinking and moderated tone, along with a mind that seems uncompromisingly bent on precision of thought and expression are traits present to such an extent that it’s difficult to see the Cardinal engaged in everyday problem solving or meet-the-press-moments that must be required of a political figure such as the Vicar of Rome.

Here then is my lineup.  Edward Pentin writes that Cardinal Scola was the “bookies’ favorite at the 2013 conclave” …but “not enough Italian cardinals could unite around him.” In no particular order, my lineup also includes Cardinal Scola as well as Italian Cardinals Piacenza and Bagnasco, Dutch Cardinal Eijk, Hungarian Cardinal Erdo,  African Cardinal Sarah, and Asian Cardinal Ranjith.  These cardinals impressed me as men capable of governing the bureaucratic Church as more than mere administrators or politicians by bringing their depth of mind and character to the office.     

 

Anatomy of a Murder by Robert Traver

This is a masculine book for those who love the legal profession. The plot is pretty straightforward. An army lieutenant is on trial for murdering the man who is alleged to have raped his wife.   The action unfolds in the remote reaches of the Upper Peninsula of Michigan during the quieter, gentler 1950s.

Three quarters of the way into the novel, I finally came to the realization that this was not a murder mystery, but a narrative-disguised-as-novel about how a lawyer defends his client.  The title just as easily might have been Anatomy of a Murder Trial.

No stone is left unturned.  We read how a defense attorney gets into the head of his client, how he constructs and tests his line of argument, how he might pour over old law journals or burn the midnight oil in mock cross-examinations with a buddy, how he plays the jury, the judge and the opposing attorney.   The trial is recounted in detail right down to and including the dialogue for the swearing-in of each witness.   

Our main character is former District Attorney Paul Biegler now sole practicing attorney of his own firm. For reasons I never figured out he goes by the nickname of Polly.  Polly is a man’s man, a bachelor who loves to fish, smoke, have a drink and practice law.  He likes women, but romance in the book is a sideline. 

The language and characters are a little dated but that made the reading more fun I thought.  For example, the psychiatrist for the defense sports a crew cut. The local townspeople bring “bag lunches” to the courtroom. Maida the secretary is just that, a secretary to whom Polly occasionally delivers a put-down or a tap on the butt.  She, in turn, says things like “Not on your life, Boss” or “You’ll do it, Boss.” 

Sprinkled about are references to an “innocent choirboy,” “two altar boys in the wake of a priest” and feeling “virtuous, like a boy scout.”  Then again, Polly admits to telling a “big whopper.” Later, it’s a boxing metaphor as Polly recounts how the prosecuting attorney “looked at me keenly, like a smart boxer stung in the first round….”  Not to be outdone, our Polly returns fire and says, “…I saw that I had scored with a sneak right.”  

Robert Traver, a pseudonym for John D. Voelker was himself a State Supreme Court Justice in Michigan.  He looks vaguely like John Wayne in some of his photos. Voelker as Traver gives the reader plenty to think about.  He includes a bit of philosophizing about life’s big issues, he paints a vivid picture of the natural beauty of the Upper Peninsula as well as of rural, small-town culture and he does a good job portraying the male characters.  However, I found his depictions of women to be little more than shallow caricatures.  Except for that, and the mini-romance which I found rather unimaginatively woven in, everything else about the book made it a good read.   

Reading History Video No. 9

February Ice Storm in Texas

 

Below is my latest video chat.  Please tune in to catch up on why three months have elapsed since my last video!  

Amy shelflife reading history blog - YouTube

Reading History@amyshelflife ---video no. 8

 

Hope you will take a look at my latest video!  Here is the link. Well, two links.  They are exactly the same content, just the comment section differs.  My computer skills are primeval, and I often overlook technical details when I upload these videos.   Again, they are exactly the same except for the comment section.  

Reading history@amyshelflife - YouTube

Reading History Video No 8 - YouTube

Two by Daphne Du Maurier

Golden Lads

Daphne Du Maurier strikes again, but this time with a book of history, Golden Lads. There seems no genre in which she doesn’t excel.  The golden lads of the title are three men of the Elizabethan court—brothers Anthony and Francis Bacon and Robert “Robin” Devereux, Earl of Essex. 

The brothers Bacon are the sons of Nicholas Bacon who was Elizabeth I’s Lord Keeper of the Seal.  They are also the nephews of William Cecil, Elizabeth’s Lord Treasurer so they are eminently well-connected at court. Devereux is a soldier and on-again-off-again favorite of Elizabeth (not in romantic sense though Durant hinted at such in Vol. 7).  Just what captured Du Maurier’s imagination about this particular trio is not clear to me, but some insights are offered here. 

St. Olave's Church where Anthony Bacon is buried

The focus of the book is on Anthony who is a spy for the court and operates at a distance from it.  If I recall correctly, he never came in direct contact with the Queen.  Anthony’s is a shadowy, solitary life with charges of homosexuality, an affinity and friendship with Montaigne and important connections to Henry IV of Navarre and France.  

Francis occupies a lesser role in the book, but we see how he cajoles, calculates and cadges to be assigned a place of power in Elizabeth’s realm.  There are hints at the Francis Bacon/William Shakespeare connection. Du Maurier has an entire book on this Bacon brother, The Winding Stair:  Francis Bacon His Rise and Fall.  Who knew she had even written about him!  I tell you, her talents are legion! 

Devereux receives the least number of pages I’d say though his life was intertwined with the lives of the Bacons in ways that I can’t neatly summarize here.  I do admit that some of the historical details blew by me.  

This is not a casual book.  Chapter by chapter sources are listed, a lot of them correspondence and official papers in addition to books of both history and literature.  Du Maurier’s research is impressive.  She informs the reader that Anthony Bacon’s letters are housed at Lambeth Palace Library and “over three hundred original letters in the collection were transcribed for me,….”  I recommend this book for its microcosmic look at the Elizabethan era.  There are pictures.  The church in the picture posted at left has significance in the book. 

 The House on the Strand

In The House on the Strand, we return to fiction, fiction that melds into history and borders on fantasy that is.  When I read the dust jacket-flap summary, a man experiments with hallucinogenic drugs, I glanced at the publication date, 1969, and thought, Oh no, has even the grande dame succumbed to writing about hippies, acid heads and addicts?  I was slow to pick up the book after that, but glad I did.  Mrs. Du Maurier had done nothing of the sort.  

This is one of the oddest, largely unbelievable yet nonetheless captivating stories I’ve ever read.  A normal man on vacation with his wife in Cornwall is the guinea pig for a drug that his friend is concocting, a drug that tampers with memory and the brain. The action see-saws between the normal man on vacation in Cornwall and that same man stumbling about that same area of Cornwall in the 14th century.  I kid you not.  I do not normally like books of this sort, almost a sci-fi feel, but Du Maurier has worked her magic. While this book is certainly not about hippies or acid-heads, there is something of the addict here, but I shan't say more.  Do read this book.

George Washington and Benedict Arnold by Dave R. Palmer (mention given to Valiant Ambition by Nathaniel Philbrick)

The publisher calls Palmer's book a dual biography.  It is subtitled A Tale of Two Patriots.  The author

laid out George Washington’s (1732-1799) and Benedict Arnold’s (1741-1801) respective lives in parallel--Washington’s childhood, Arnold’s childhood; Washington’s early adult years, Arnold’s early adult years.  Then the Revolutionary War begins.  

In 1775, Washington is in Boston, Arnold at Fort Ticonderoga.  In 1776, Washington is losing Manhattan and the lower Hudson, Arnold is fighting to a draw against the Brits and managing to hold the upper Hudson for the patriots.  In 1777 Washington is losing the Battle of the Brandywine in September while Arnold is victorious at, first, the Battle of Ridgefield and then the Battle of Freeman’s Farm (Saratoga).  So it goes.  The parallels cease of course when Arnold turns to treason in 1779 and finagles a command at West Point so that he can hand the post over to the British.

Much has been written about Washington’s personality. Flawed as all humans are, George Washington was nonetheless a man of tremendous character.  He consistently practiced honesty, self-control, altruism and prudent judgment. He was courageous in battle, frequently riding into the heat of a fray. Recognized as an excellent horseman, he was a physically imposing figure, mindful of his appearance and reputation, ambitious in his goals.  Yet, he was relied upon by the majority of his contemporaries as the man who could exercise oversight with fairness and guide the unsteady nation with prudence.   

Benedict Arnold was also one of the most courageous, fighting men in the Revolutionary War, and, like Washington he had drive and spirit. Arnold, however, was a self-serving man with a fiery, combative personality. He was impulsive, often aggressive and brusque.  Arnold never felt he got the recognition he deserved for his military achievements (it’s hard not to agree with him) and he was preoccupied with wealth and all its outward trappings.  What made Arnold turn on the cause for which he had had such passion?  Most agree that it was ego, ambition and money.  His second wife, young Peggy Shippen of Philadelphia, equally materialistic and ambitious, is believed to have urged him on in his decision to betray the Revolution.  

In addition to the biographical chapters at the beginning of the book, the author takes the reader through the battles of the war leading up to and including Arnold’s treason at West Point.  Palmer closes out his book with a look at why these two lives ceased to march in parallel.

The author, Dave Palmer, is Retired Lt General Dave Palmer who was a 1956 graduate of the United States Military Academy at West Point and superintendent of the same from 1986 to 199.  How fitting then that Palmer examines his subjects according to the goals of the institution so much a part of his life.  The U.S. Military Academy aims to turn its cadets into leaders of character.  Character, Palmer explains, hinges on virtue---fortitude (physical and moral courage), temperance (control of the passions and appetites), prudence (practical wisdom and the ability to know right from wrong, make right decisions) and justice (fairness, honesty, lawfulness, loyalty).  Palmer evaluates Washington and Arnold in each of the four virtues.  No surprise that General Washington scores 100 on all four.  And Arnold?

Palmer gives him full credit in only one category, fortitude. Arnold’s battlefield drive, his willingness to go to the front line, his taking a stand once he began something and his good mind on the battlefield regardless of danger to himself distinguish him in this category.  On prudence Arnold gets half credit.  Palmer reasons that Arnold did show good judgment in matters of combat though he could not sustain that judgment off the battlefield.  On temperance Arnold rates a zero. Arnold consistently indulged his emotions and his desire for material rewards. Lastly, justice was a huge problem for someone of Arnold’s self-absorption and self-indulgence. He promoted himself over others (even his wife).  He was dishonest when convenient and practiced deception recklessly and without remorse in order to achieve his goals. 

Palmer’s style is very readable and he takes seriously his analysis of the character and leadership qualities of these two historic figures.  This comparison was missing from Nathaniel Philbrick’s Valiant Ambition though I should mention that reading Philbrick’s book first probably helped make Palmer’s book easier reading! Palmer’s book needs many more maps and could use a few more photographs.  However, the photos that are included are not the routine; photos are credited to the Mount Vernon Ladies’ Association, Norwich Historical Society and The Granger Collection.  I would recommend Palmer over Philbrick for the West Point perspective and thoughtful comparison Palmer brought to the subject.  

Finally, Palmer leaves us a visual of our two generals.  At West Point, a statue of George Washington on horseback dominates the Plain, a center point of the post.  Still on post but down the road and out of sight unless you make the trip is the old Cadet Chapel.  Inside, Palmer explains, are plaques that carry the names, rank, birth date and death date of heroes of American battles.  The single plaque that lists only rank and date of birth is Arnold's.  Benedict Arnold's name does not appear.  No date of death is given.  As Palmer writes, “…traitors never die, they simply cease to exist.”    

Six Books of Young Adult Fiction

Young Adult Fiction (YAF) is a category of writing for readers ages 12-18. The key characteristic of YAF is that the protagonist be a teenager. The themes are usually those of self-discovery, coming-of-age, figuring out the world and one’s role in it.  What is my purpose in life? What do I believe? Why am I here? Who am I?  The writing is in-the-moment as opposed to reflection or reverse chronologies.  The books I’ll discuss here are not current titles in YAF.  They are mostly nostalgia reading on my part.  By the way, 55% of YAF readers are adults.  I am not alone. 

First up, A Ring of Endless Light by Madeleine L’Engle (1980).  The protagonist is sixteen-year- old Vicky Austin, a sensitive and smart teen who writes poetry and is choosing among three very different suitors.  The story opens with the funeral of the father of one her suitors, Leo, a still-gawky but good-hearted adolescent. The next is Zachary, an urbane, rich boy.  Then there’s Adam who studies dolphins at the nearby Marine Biology Station for the summer.  Adam is college-age and suavely intellectual.  

The Austin family is also quite intellectual as well as refined and accomplished.  They read Shakespeare after dinner.  They sing together accompanied by their almost-professional mother on the guitar.  The oldest brother goes to MIT and Dad is a doctor doing research.  Grandfather is dying and he’s benevolent and patient, filled with the wisdom of the ages.  I felt overwhelmed by the lofty perfection.  

My introduction to Madeline L’Engle was A Wrinkle in Time in the 5^th grade.  I loved the book.  As with that book, this book also has elements of the supernatural.  Although L’Engle’s overall message is one that reflects a tenderness for adolescence guided by traditional values and Christian teachings, I found unsettling her particular admixture of traditional and Christian with a New Age, sixth-sense-supernatural perspective.  This short bio of Ms. L’Engle explains her outlook well I think and helped me understand why she writes as she does.  While I can see the value in this book for some readers, it did not resonate with me at all nor would it have resonated had I read it at 16.  Vicky was likeable, but even at my advanced age, I still can’t imagine why anyone would want to swim with dolphins let alone talk to them.  That is just not real life.     

Next on the list are four books with a male protagonist. The Story of Mad Anthony Wayne by Hazel Wilson (1953) tells of the life and times of Revolutionary War hero, Anthony Wayne.  This is a volume in the Signature Books series by Grosset & Dunlap. Wayne is from my hometown area in southeastern Pennsylvania.  This book is well-written and takes us through Wayne’s childhood, military career and later life. This is an excellent and thorough biography of a man who exhibited fire and courage and love of country.

Adam of the Road (1942) is by Elizabeth Janet Gray whom I’ve written about here. This is a father-son story set in late 13^th century England.  Eleven-year-old Adam is separated from his minstrel father, Roger, about midway through the book. Adam’s literal search for his father is a spiritual sort of search for himself.  Adam loves and reveres his father and wants also to be a minstrel. This book of historical fiction is not heavy on plot, but there are good guys and bad guys along the way.  There is challenge and adventure and plenty of information about the era (the book could have used a glossary for all the medieval vocabulary). The story is charmingly told and has an important message about fathers and sons.  The last words of the book are Roger speaking to Adam.  “You have done well, son.”  What young man would not want to hear those words from his father.

The Sign of the Beaver (1983) is written by Elizabeth George Speare.  Here is young Matt, about to turn 13, left to mind the family’s new frontier cabin and property while his father goes back to civilization to pack up the household and then return to the wilderness with the rest of the family. The year is 1769 or so and the setting is Maine. Like My Side of the Mountain, this is a wilderness survival tale, but Speare is more clearly intent on presenting a coming-of-age story.  Matt grows up by developing the virtues of loyalty and courage.  He learns about himself and the world through friendship with others. Matt perseveres and his father’s words to him at the end of the book are: “You’ve done a grown man’s job, son.   I’m right proud of you.”  More words for young men to grow on.

Sam Gribley is another young man on a journey of sorts. The book is Jean Craighead George’s My Side of the Mountain (1959).  Sam runs away from home, which is an apartment on Third Avenue in NYC, and lives off the land in the Catskills.  His home away from home is a large hemlock tree.  He hunts, fishes and gathers based on an encyclopedic knowledge of the flora and fauna of the woods.  To keep warm and cook, he constructs an indoor fireplace.  He sews his clothes from animal furs and skins. He befriends weasels and raccoons, and he raises and trains a hawk. Sam doesn’t get fleas or even mosquito bites and he is only sickly once.   Whew! 

The author clearly knows whereof she speaks when describing wilderness survival. She offers some explanation of her knowledge in the introduction.  The illustrations of plants and objects are her own. Yet, while it’s an engaging story, it was entirely unbelievable to me, fantasy without a purpose.  I simply could not relate. Despite the author’s introductory remark that there is a universal kid-desire to run away from home, I never even remotely considered such an awful thing. 

Maybe this is more of a boy’s passage-into-manhood book.  Young Sam certainly does very manly things and exhibits a lot of gutsy confidence to spend so much time all alone with forest animals, snowstorms and passing strangers.   I won’t give away the ending except to say that Sam’s father is more of a 60s kind of free spirit.     

I’ve saved the best for last.  In my opinion, everyone should read The Bronze Bow by Elizabeth George Speare (1961).  The author has ingeniously and succinctly explained what it means to be a man (and indirectly a woman) and to follow Christ.  That’s a pretty tall order for a work of YAF.  The setting is the Holy Land in the year 30 AD or thereabouts.  Jesus is one of the characters in the story as is Simon the Zealot who will become one of Christ’s twelve apostles.  The protagonist is Daniel, a Jew of probably 15 to 18 years of age, whose rage against the Romans along with his expectations of the coming Messiah have driven him to an outlaw’s life.  Daniel has a choice to make as to what kind of man he will be and how he will fight for freedom.  There’s action and suspense right up to the end.  In fact, I became quite agitated reading the last ten pages as I awaited Daniel’s choice. 

I read this as a younger self not knowing much about the life and times of Christ. Nonetheless, Speare’s young protagonists and their concerns must have emerged to me as understandable and genuine. Their thoughts and dilemmas must have drawn me in.  The inclusion of Jesus as a walking, talking character in the narrative must have brought the past into the present and, again, I was drawn in.  So it was this time reading as an adult.  Ms. Speare is a wonderful writer. 

I hope you'll choose from among these titles to read for yourself or pass along to kids and grandkids.  

Video Number 7

Hope you'll tune in my next video, Number 7, with special guests!  Link is below:  

Reading History No 7@Amy Shelflife - YouTube

Reading History Video No.6

Upstairs at my parents' house

In this video, I chat about a website named Reshelving Alexandria and a couple other topics as well.  I hope you have a few minutes to pull up a chair and watch.  Reading History No.6 - YouTube

Henry VIII The King and His Court by Alison Weir

Another English historian has proved dry and lackluster. Alison Weir has tons and tons of detail in this biography of Henry the VIII (1491-1547) but very few summations or discussions of overarching themes that define Henry’s era and his reign.  The reader is on one’s own to read and read and read and infer from the details what the core ideas might be. Weir writes in a chronological style, shares little to no opinion of her own, is only occasionally enthusiastic about her subject and supplants imagination with abundant detail. We read and read and read but, I do repeat myself. Actually I often didn’t read.  I did a lot of skimming. 

Henry VIII, whose reign extended from 1509-1547 is of course known for his six wives and his role in establishing the Church of England.   The book did dig in a bit where the wives were concerned and provided a closeup view of each and the sort of relationship each had with Henry.  I was glad to read that his first wife, the beleaguered Catharine of Aragon--oops that’s Katherine with a “K” for the Brits--was not as forsaken and ill-treated as I had thought.  She and Henry did have some good years together during which there was a fondness and attachment.  

Of the six wives, I found the last Katharine, Katharine Parr, to be of particular interest at least in part because her queenship reflected the progressive vs. conservative religious tension of the day.  Katharine Parr was something of a thinker and activist, a participant in the controversies of the day. She wrote and published at least two books about prayer.   She had about her a group of like-minded women among whom was perhaps Anne Askew, a Protestant who was eventually arrested and tortured on charges of heresy.  Katharine also fell solidly into the progressive/Protestant camp but, like Henry himself and so many other members of the court, Parr was outwardly Catholic.  Though not necessarily due to her connections with Askew, conservatives of the court suspected Katharine of heresy and issued a warrant for her arrest on charges of the same. Henry rather unwittingly gave his signature to the warrant, but nothing came of it.

 As for Henry himself? Ms. Weir credits Henry VIII with a long list of accomplishments---founding The  Church of England, advancing parliamentary government, enriching the “standing” of the monarchy, guiding England “courageously through a religious revolution,” and reconstructing “the machinery of state.”  He was a lover of art, he “created the most magnificent court in English history” and he “took England from medieval to modern.”  Quite a resume for a man who could scarcely bury one wife before marrying the next.     

Any accomplishments of Henry VIII’s reign are vastly overshadowed by his central interest---himself.  I would describe him as impulsive, self-absorbed and self-indulgent. He lacked leadership ability and was not as a rule particularly compassionate or kind. Though said to be intelligent and even scholarly, he seemed unaware that his actions were sowing the seeds for the death of the Catholic faith in England and the division of Christendom in Europe. He also failed in a large way to appreciate that his rejection of papal authority was diametrically opposed to his identity as a Catholic. Henry VIII persecuted his share of Protestants while he also presided over the destruction of the Catholic monasteries, the Annates Act of 1532 (which re-directed taxes paid to the Vatican to Henry instead) and The Act of Supremacy of 1534 which clinched the separation of England from the Church of Rome. Yet he died a “Catholic” with his burial mass given by Bishop Gardiner, the more conservative Catholic wing of the religious controversy.  

Ms. Weir writes that history has typically portrayed Henry VIII as an ogre who killed his wives and mis-treated his subjects, but such should not be our conclusion.  Given the “wealth of modern research” we can now see the “charisma” of the real Henry VIII who so capably reigned.  With all due respect for Alison Weir’s extensive scholarship, I go with the outdated Henry-as-ogre. At the end of the day, Henry VIII was a shallow man, an uncaring father, a fickle husband and a feckless leader. 

Reading History No 5 Video

Late Summer Clouds

Here’s the link to my most recent video. I’m branching out a bit to topics other than reading history and I’ll also be having specially chosen guests! 

In the video I mention the author Elizabeth Janet Gray Vining. Besides retiring in my hometown of Kennett Saure, PA, Mrs. Vining was a very remarkable woman who wrote a book about her years as English tutor to the Crown Prince of Japan after WWII.  Here is my commentary on Mrs. Vining’s book.

Columbus and The Crisis of The West by Robert Royal

We know who Columbus is but what is the crisis of the west?  Or The West?  This book examines the vilification of Columbus and the “woke” notion that Western Civilization is racist, evil, exploitative and garbage.  It’s a notion that’s been around since the 60s of course but is enjoying a rebirth of freedom now.  

Robert Royal, academician and Catholic writer extraordinaire has tackled the attacks on Columbus and the contributions of Western Civilization to the development of the modern world.  There’s a lot of information in this book plus good arguments in the defense of Columbus and Western Civilization.  Mr. Royal’s information on Columbus and the Spanish empire in the New World is accurate and unbiased.  He certainly does not whitewash either.  

The book is difficult. It reads like a compilation of speeches or articles with added text to attempt a coherent whole.  Royal’s writing is, not surprisingly, academic in style.  It’s a bit abstruse.  The analysis is nuanced and detailed with long sentences and the occasional choice of word that clogs up the understanding. Any number of times I found myself thinking, Why doesn’t he just say what he means and let’s get on with it. I had thought I might go back and unravel the chapters a bit.  If I ever do that I will also undertake better note-taking in the margins.  

There is valuable information in this book if you feel called upon to defend Columbus as a bold explorer, an accomplished mariner and an essential historical figure who was central in ushering in the modern age.  

Also read Samuel Eliot Morrison’s Admiral of the Ocean Sea:  A Life of Christopher Columbus. I really liked that book. 

Reading History No. 4 and Related Links

 

Here is the link to my July 4th Reading History video:

Reading History No. 4 - YouTube

Here are some related links!  

 This is a list of all 185 books in the Landmark Series:

http://cherylbastian.blogspot.com/2013/07/landmark-books-in-chronological-order.html

Two good articles about Landmark Books:

http://www.historians.org/publications-and-directories/perspectives-on-history/october-2016/generation-past-the-story-of-the-landmark-books

Landmark Books – First-Rate History Series for Readers and Collectors | Old Scrolls Blog (wordpress.com)

Exodus Books is a good website for shopping and learning: 

Landmark Reprints - Exodus Books

Landmark Giants - Exodus Books

American Landmark Books - Exodus Books

Childhood of Famous Americans - Exodus Books

Here are two links on the 1619 Project: 

The 1619 Project - The New York Times (nytimes.com)

Pulitzer Center: 1619 Project (1619education.org)